Global News

Supreme Court Grapples With Texas Redistricting Case

Supreme Court Grapples With Texas Redistricting Case

The Supreme Court hears oral arguments Tuesday in a case that could not only require Texas to redraw its congressional districts, but give states a way to defend against claims of gerrymandering. A three-judge district court in San Antonio has issued multiple rulings finding the maps discriminatory against Latino and African American voters, but had not yet completed the remedy stage when Texas successfully sought a stay in the case from Justice Samuel Alito. Scott A. Keller, Texas' solicitor general, said state lawmakers had adopted the maps after substantial debate and deliberation.

The plaintiffs in the Texas case then amended their challenge, contesting both the 2011 maps and the new plans the Legislature had just passed.

"The district court in Texas trampled on law and logic alike in order to wrest from the people of Texas their authority - through their duly elected representatives - to control their legislative districts". But seven years into legal wrangling over Texas lawmakers' efforts to redraw the state's maps, the punchy legal briefs have already served to crystallize the frustration surrounding the prolonged - and convoluted - litigation. "Now, if we're going to call that a grant of an injunction, we're going to hear 50,000 appeals from however many three-judge courts there are".

Added Justice Elena Kagan: "And what I'm concerned about is that if you're right, we're going to be hearing all of these districting cases not after the remedial stage but, instead, straight away after the liability stage".

That question was not in front of the Supreme Court on Wednesday, but the challengers plan to use this case to ask the district court to put Texas back under pre-clearance under the VRA's Section 3, which allows states and jurisdictions to be "bailed in" if they are found to have acted with intent to discriminate against minority voters.

Pointing to the lawmakers' 2013 adoption of a court-drawn map that was meant to be temporary, the groups chronicled the actions as "a ruse", a "shellgame strategy" and a devious "smokescreen" meant to obscure discriminatory motives behind a previous redistricting plan.




Opponents of the legislative lines argue the state should not have appealed the initial decision directly to the Supreme Court.

But some of the justices were concerned that following Texas' reasoning would lead the court's inbox to be flooded with appeals of lower court decisions. Because it is likely too late to fix those maps in time for the 2018 elections, even if Texas loses this round, it will have had kept in place maps found to be intentionally discriminatory in eight out of 10 years of elections. That was when lawmakers embarked on redrawing the state's congressional and legislative districts to account for explosive growth, particularly among Hispanic residents, following the 2010 census. Justice Sonia Sotomayor asked. They flagged areas of the state where the boundaries today remain unchanged between the two maps.

"You have instances where the courts have said this is some intentional discrimination or there's unconstitutional gerrymandering", Rodriguez said in an interview on "State of Texas".

That move, the state contends, was a "conciliatory act" in which the Legislature "embraced the court's maps for the perfectly permissible reason that it wanted to bring the litigation to an end".

Edwin S. Kneedler, a lawyer for the federal government arguing in support of Texas, said it was a mistake to apply the flaws in the earlier map to the later one.

Attorney General Ken Paxton announced last week that Gov.


  • You May Be Eligible for a Hefty Discount on Dark Souls Remastered

    You May Be Eligible for a Hefty Discount on Dark Souls Remastered

    The original Dark Souls turns seven this year, and we're just now starting to feel the full weight of its influence. That's the day that the highly anticipated Dark Souls: Remastered hits store shelves for the PS4, Xbox One and PC.
    Wolfenstein II:The New Colossus makes the Switch on June 29

    Wolfenstein II:The New Colossus makes the Switch on June 29

    And, for the ideal blend of immersion and accuracy, utilize the Nintendo Switch's unique motion controls to stop the Nazi threat. Bethesda Softworks today announced the final release date for the Nintendo Switch port of Wolfenstein II: The New Colossus .
    Spotify launches a new mobile app with more free features

    Spotify launches a new mobile app with more free features

    Spotify now has approximately 159 million users, 71 million of whom use paid subscription services. Spotify said it now has 159 million users, 70 million of which are paid subscribers.
  • Mike Pompeo's Path To Foggy Bottom Becomes Clearer

    Mike Pompeo's Path To Foggy Bottom Becomes Clearer

    Isakson was delivering the eulogy for a friend in Atlanta, and was unable to return to Washington until later in the evening. Majority Leader Mitch McConnell said there were enough votes in the full Senate to confirm Pompeo this week.
    Maoists' Bodies Float In River, Toll Now Put At 27

    Maoists' Bodies Float In River, Toll Now Put At 27

    Search and combing operations continue, though interrupted by heavy rain and bad weather, in the entire Gadchiroli district. While six Maoists were killed in the Rajaram Khanla encounter, four of them were women, Police officials said.
    Shahid Kapoor and Mira Rajput all set to welcome their second baby!

    Shahid Kapoor and Mira Rajput all set to welcome their second baby!

    He is very deserving of all the applause that he is getting. "Of course he just begun but he's lots to know and a long way togo. Shahid Kapoor's brother Ishaan Khatter is all set to embark on his Bollywood journey and the audience can't wait for to happen.
  • Gronkowski (the horse) has setback and will miss Kentucky Derby

    Gronkowski (the horse) has setback and will miss Kentucky Derby

    This insane press conference was basically him sticking his tongue out at Bill Belichick . Maybe I'll go for a full speed ride once I get comfortable".
    Super Bowl Champion Eagles Invited To White House

    Super Bowl Champion Eagles Invited To White House

    Shear of the New York Times obtained a recording of Lurie criticizing the president during a private league meeting in October. Malcolm Jenkins , Chris Long , Torrey Smith and LeGarrette Blount have all said they would not attend a meeting with Trump.
    Britain's TSB bank still facing problem with app, online banking

    Britain's TSB bank still facing problem with app, online banking

    The bank has also reinvented itself as a challenger bank, with the latest technologies at the core of its strategy. The 20-year-old told the BBC: "I saw the details of one other account holder, as well as my own".
  • NAR: Existing-Home Sales Eked Out an Increase in March

    NAR: Existing-Home Sales Eked Out an Increase in March

    Distressed sales - foreclosures and short sales - were 4% of sales in March, unchanged from February and down from 6% a year ago. The median sales price for an existing home in the region was $270,600 - an increase of 3.3 percent from past year .

    Ranking the Top-5 NFL Draft needs for the Chicago Bears

    There are five quarterbacks teams have fallen in love with, and they're going to do everything they can to grab them. At this point in time, it doesn't seem terribly likely that Barkley will fall down to No. 10 in the draft.
    BBNaija victor : Miracle's name did the magic, says Musician

    BBNaija victor : Miracle's name did the magic, says Musician

    What will you do with the prize money: I'll use part of the money to further my pilot training and the rest to help my family. In all, 170 million votes were cast in the 85-day event, with 30 million votes coming in this week alone.